A budget cut too far 25/1/13
An open letter to Catriona Stewart, Education chairperson
Thank you for your reply
to my email detailing your position on the subject of the removal of itinerant teachers.
I am of the opinion that you are failing to take any note of what the public are
telling you. Not one person, including the Comhairle's officers and members present,
at either of the Stornoway meetings, suggested cutting primary teachers out of the
equation or, indeed, even intimated that had been, or should ever be, considered.
Not one single person stood up and supported the removal -
The proposal is not support by parents, Parent Councils, staff, senior teachers -
The issue of instructors is something that cannot be relied on. As detailed at the recent meeting, these instructors have limited space, scope, time and, with all due respect, are not teachers. They maybe experts on one or two aspects of their chosen field, but cannot hope to cover the same amount of diversity the itinerants cover. One parent at the meeting explained at some length to the Chair that her daughter had to draw straws to see if she could get music instruction at her school. This cannot be part of a solution.
My understanding of some of the extra provision, such as active schools, is that they are funded externally by groups such as Sport Scotland. Currently, according to CNES website, they cater only for upper primary children and older. This is also true of music instructors and YMI. I am not even sure that there is any other provision available for Art. What happens when these agencies are forced to pull funding? We do not have the resources in the Western Isles to provide these activities outwith the school. Even if we did, I fear it would only be for the wealthier inhabitants. This will, in the not too distant future, result in families leaving the islands, something the Comhairle has committed to addressing.
After speaking to some elected members, they are of the opinion that a reduced, more streamlined service would be feasible and desirable. Has this been looked into or has the big scythe become immovable?
In my original email, I asked why can we not be better than other authorities. I still await an answer on that.
I fully appreciate the fact that cuts need to be made, but this is too far. It is
not acceptable to the public and therefore, I implore you to find a different solution.
This is why we have elected members and pay officers -
Graham Cay
18 MacSween Drive
Aird
Point
Lewis
Letters require the writer’s full name and full address before publication. Please
send your letter in the body of an e-