Local Services   I Cars  I   Stuff 4 Sale   I   Jobs   I                             



Communism is a religion too        29/11/13



Donald J Morrison (Letters, 25 November) makes the usual mistake of assuming communism has nothing to do with religion, and further conveniently ignores centuries of oppression by Christianity, shored up with its inquisitions, crusades and repressive blasphemy laws.

Communism merely replaces an omnipotent god with an omnipotent state, and has its prophets, sacred texts, inquisitions, leader devotion, forced worship, and beatification and indoctrination rituals in common with belief in gods.

The historian Simon Sebag Montefiore notes in his excellent 2007 work "Young Stalin" that it was in his Tiflis seminary that Stalin (yes, a former trainee priest) learned "exactly the repressive tactics - surveillance, spying, invasion of inner life and violation of feelings, in Stalin's own words - that he would recreate in his Soviet police state."

That doesn't excuse his crimes, of course, but it does give one pause to wonder how differently things might have turned out if had Stalin had never wanted to be a priest. Montefiore reports another former seminarist and contemporary of Stalin's stating "no secular school produced as many atheists as the Tiflis seminary."

Alistair McBay

National Secular Society

5 Atholl Crescent



Letters @hebrides.biz

Letters should be sent within the body of an e-mail - no attachments, please - and require the writer’s full name, full address and phone number before publication.